Inside: Cakes & Ale

Raise a glass to this Decatur eatery

By Rachael Mason

Special to Metromix
June 27, 2008

 
Critic's Rating:
3 1/2

Inside: Cakes & Ale
Cakes Arancini (Credit: Jeff Moore: Green Olive Media)

Located in pedestrian friendly downtown Decatur, Cakes & Ale is the perfect place to see and be seen—especially if you’re sitting at one of the coveted front window seats. Of course, if you’d prefer just to relax, you can order a pint of beer (ale is just one of many options) or a glass of wine at the bar.

The restaurant is open only for dinner Tuesday through Saturday, so be sure to make reservations to guarantee a place at this new neighborhood favorite.

Atmosphere: The decor of the dining room, with its clean lines, booth seating and simple black-and-silver color scheme, has a sophisticated retro feel that suits the downtown location. Despite the use of black, the restaurant still has a bright and airy feel, courtesy of the floor-to-ceiling windows that make up one long wall. Daily specials are written in white chalk on a blackboard that hangs at the front of the restaurant.

Though the space is intimate, there’s still plenty of room between each table. This keeps the restaurant from feeling overcrowded even on busy Friday and Saturday nights. While you’ll definitely be able to eavesdrop on nearby conversations, the dining room isn’t so loud that you’ll have trouble hearing what the people at your own table are saying. 

Chef: At Cakes & Ale, the chef is Billy Allin, a native of South Carolina who studied at the California Culinary Academy in San Francisco. His experience includes two years as sous chef at Watershed, a nationally recognized Decatur eatery focusing on Southern cuisine. At his restaurant, which he owns with his wife Kristin, Allin’s accessible menu features foods made from scratch using local ingredients whenever possible.

Food: With a focus on seasonal fare and locally produced items, including Georgia-grown grains, vegetables and fruits, the restaurant’s offerings change daily. The menu, which is printed on a sheet of long paper, is divided into three sections.

The first features a list of appetizers and salads—including pimento cheese fingers and pickles, which are a house favorite. The pimento fingers can be compared to a grilled cheese sandwich, cut into easy-to-eat sticks, and are made with enough butter to make Paula Deen proud. They come four to an order, along with a bowl of housemade sweet pickles, but you could easily eat many, many more of them.

However, you must control your urge for more of the cheesy, buttery delights to save room for a main course, chosen from the second section of the menu. Though the list of entrees changes often, the Cakes & Ale burger is a constant. Made with a mix of beef brisket and pork, this burger goes miles beyond typical ground beef in terms of flavor and appeal. On the plate, the burger supports a huge pile of crunchy and irresistible shoestring fries.

The potato gnocchi is the kind of dish that you won’t be able to stop thinking about, even days after you try it. The presentation of this dish varies and the gnocchi may be tossed with peas and fennel sausage, a mushroom cream sauce or greens and slivers of parmesan cheese.

The restaurant also serves up entrees of organic chicken, as well as flatiron steak, salmon and lamb.

Section three of the menu is dedicated to sweets, including the signature “phatty” cakes, which are more like cookie sandwiches than the cake the name implies. The frozen treats are particularly hard to resist during the hot days of June, July and August. Keep an eye out for the watermelon-and-honeydew slushie on the ever-changing menu. This fresh fruit treat perfectly captures the flavors of summer.

Drinks: Beer is a major focus, of course, but the restaurant also stocks quite a few bottles of wine that come everywhere from California and Oregon to Spain and South Africa. Daily wine specials vary and may include varieties like a fizzy Pinot Noir that’s definitely worth trying.

The beer list also changes frequently, but could include draft choices such as Allagash White from Maine, Highland Oatmeal Porter from North Carolina and Red Seal Ale from California. Bottled brews such as Dale’s Pale Ale and J.K. Scrumpy’s Hard Cider are also served.

 

Cakes & Ale
254 W. Ponce de Leon Ave.
Decatur, GA 30030
404-377-7994
Hours: Tue.-Sat. 5:30 p.m.-10:30 p.m.
Reservations recommended

What other people are saying...

ClaireCWID from Inman Park - July 21, 2009 at 3:48 PM

Absolutely it delivers and in such a beautiful space! If you don't get your fill of sweets here, stop by The Chocolate Bar next door.

Report This Comment

Add a comment

Please log in to comment

More on Metromix.com

Ornament-bottom-yellow